First Coast Cigar Guide
Visit notes / A midday stop at Island Girl

Fleming Island · Clay County

A midday stop at Island Girl, Fleming Island

By Les. Visited October 6, 2026. I paid for my own cigar and drink.

The main room of Island Girl Cigar Bar: round tables with black leather chairs in front, a long bar with stools at the back, and TVs on the walls.
The main room at Island Girl.

I stopped in at Island Girl on Fleming Island in the middle of the day. It was a light crowd, four to six regulars, and they were friendly and chatty. It felt like a neighborhood bar where people know each other.

Sandi was working. Super friendly, and offered to help me choose a cigar.

I went with a Perdomo 12 year, a very good smoke for under $15, and had a bourbon, neat, with it. The walk-in humidor has single cigars from $5.50 to $55, so there’s room to spend less or more.

Smoking is inside only. There are about 20 seats at a large bar, and the rest of the room is tables and couches. Great neighborhood bar atmosphere, highly recommended.

See the full listing